I don’t know if it’s quite cricket but I’m going to answer a question Richie presented to Conor from Vendetta a few days ago regarding stainless lugs.
http://www.velocipedesalon.com/forum...s-15630-4.html
I’ve struggled with stainless and although I would like to offer it for clients, many times I think I’m not going to anymore.
My take on it is if I’m going to do it at all then it has to rival the work of Dazza or Dave Bohm. Lofty thoughts maybe but that’s the goal.
One concern I had early on was poor castings on some lugs that revealed voids after spending much time sanding. This is on main triangles that have already had much time spent on them. If they're small then it may not be a problem for the client.The next question is what to tell the client? If the client decides to just paint then I've still wasted the time spent getting that far.
The next thing is the time it takes to get quality polished stainless. I’ve made three frames this year with the whole stainless treatment. Lugs/crown and sometimes drops, I don’t do stainless bottom brackets so that settles at least one question. The time it takes me to go through the steps puts me behind on other pending builds and even though I charge a fair amount, it’s not the same as time spent on the frame.
And then there’s the mess! The sanding part isn’t too bad but is pretty hard on your hands. Sometimes I just get away from it for a few days and work on other projects till they feel better. The final buffing may be a small part of the process for shinyness but makes one nasty mess all over the shop if you don’t have an exclusive dirt room or do it outside like Dazza then it’ll take even more time to clean everything. $$
One other problem is what to do about paint & clear coat. One camp doesn’t clear over the lugs, this gives the advantage of being able to polish out scratches after the frame has been painted. The trade off is the lug edges may be exposed and paint can flake off.
JB clears all the stainless and I assume does the same for all the builders who send stainless his way. The issue with the lug edges is solved but the stainless now cannot be buffed or the clear will blur. If the stainless gets any kind of nick or scratch at the painters then it will be under the clear for good.
The question comes up about chrome plating as an alternative. For most instances I prefer the look of stainless over chrome so lean to stainless for that reason. If a frame is going to get any plating, I would prefer to polish it anyway to ensure nothing bad happens to it.
In my not so brief explanation, I guess I’m going to continue for now but I there may come a day that I say it’s just not my cup of tea anymore.
Bookmarks